top of page


Click-to-Open Rate


Increase Month over Month


Increase in Sales

Valley of the Moon Marketing: A Case Study on Transforming Financial Marketing for Travis Credit Union

1. Introduction:
This case study delves into the collaboration between Valley of the Moon Marketing and Travis Credit Union, a financial institution, to revamp their marketing approach. The focus was on targeting Millennials and Gen Z with a Millennial-first messaging strategy, incorporating vibrant and on-trend visuals. By conducting A/B testing and leveraging data-driven insights, Valley of the Moon Marketing successfully implemented a groundbreaking campaign that surpassed industry norms and resulted in significant growth for Travis Credit Union in the first quarter of 2019.

2. Objectives:
a. Develop Millennial-first messaging for complicated bank products.
b. Stand out from competitors through unique and on-trend visual elements.
c. Increase open rates and engagement among the target audience.
d. Achieve substantial growth for Travis Credit Union in the first quarter of 2019.

3. Methods and Implementation:
a. Identifying Target Audience Preferences:
   - Conducted thorough research on the Millennial and Gen Z demographics, focusing on their preferences,           interests, and trends.
   - Recognized the demand for relevant and on-trend content that resonates with the target audience.

b. A/B Testing and Image-Centric Approach:
   - Recognized the impact of visuals on engagement and conducted A/B testing to evaluate the effectiveness        of different approaches.
   - Group A received an email with an attention-grabbing image and headline, while the product description             took a secondary role.
   - Group B received a different email with a less captivating image and headline.
   - Monitored open rates and analyzed heat maps to assess user engagement and preferences.

c. Results and Analysis:
   - Group A with the striking headline "Bump Up the Volume" achieved an exceptional open rate of 30%,                surpassing the typical rate of 20%.
   - The heat map analysis indicated that users were drawn to click on the image, demonstrating the                             effectiveness of the visual element.
   - In contrast, Group B had a dismal open rate of 5%, accompanied by indications of a desire to unsubscribe.

4. Campaign Launch and Results:
   - Based on the successful A/B testing results, Travis Credit Union launched a marketing campaign                           incorporating the image-centric approach and captivating messaging.
   - The unique and vibrant campaign stood out from competitors and generated significant growth for Travis            Credit Union during the first quarter of 2019.

5. Conclusion:
Valley of the Moon Marketing's collaboration with Travis Credit Union led to the successful transformation of its financial marketing approach. By employing a Millennial-first messaging strategy and incorporating visually captivating elements, the campaign achieved outstanding results. The A/B testing confirmed that the image played a more significant role than the headline in attracting and engaging the target audience. The campaign's remarkable open rate and positive user feedback demonstrated the effectiveness of the unique and on-trend approach, ultimately driving substantial growth for Travis Credit Union. This case study showcases the importance of data-driven insights, creative thinking, and understanding target audience preferences in developing successful marketing campaigns within the financial industry.

beautiful drawing of a succulent plant

Let’s Work Together

Get in touch so we can start working together.

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page